Overtourism

Excesses, Discontents and Measures in Travel and Tourism

Claudio Milano, Joseph M Cheer, Marina Novelli, Claudio Milano, Joseph M Cheer, Marina Novelli

• Publisher: CAB International
• Year: 2019
• ISBN:
  9781786399847
• Topic: Business
• Subtopic: Hospitality, Travel & Tourism Industry
• Index: Business

This book examines the evolution of the phenomenon and explores the genesis of overtourism and the system dynamics underlining it.The 'overtourism' phenomenon is defined as the excessive growth of visitors leading to overcrowding and the consequential suffering of residents, due to temporary and often seasonal tourism peaks, that lead to permanent changes in lifestyles, amenities and well- being. Enormous tensions in overtourism affected destinations have driven the intensification of policy making and scholarly attention toward seeking antidotes to an issue that is considered paradoxical and problematic. Moving beyond the 'top 10 things you can do about overtourism', this book examines the evolution of the phenomenon and explores the genesis of overtourism as well as the system dynamics underpinning it. With a rigorous scientific approach, the book uses systems-thinking and contemporary paradigms around sustainable development, resilience planning and degrowth; while considering global economic, socio-political, environmental discourses. This book: - Deconstructs 'overtourism' and considers the many constituent parts that have led to its current conceptualisations; - Presents globally diverse views of overtourism through numerous case studies; - Is written in plain language accessible to readers beyond the academic context. Researchers, analysts, policy makers and industry stakeholders working within tourism as well as those within the private sector, community groups, civil society groups and NGOs will find this book an essential source of information.

1 Venice: An Analysis of Tourism Excesses in an Overtourism Icon

FRANCESCO VISENTIN,* AND DARIO BERTOCCHI

Department of Economics, Ca’ Foscari University of Venice, Italy

1.1 Introduction

Tourism, as a sector characterized by a set of activities overlapping with the everyday, leads to long-standing conventions and ways of life being reinforced or ruptured. Rather than transcending the everyday, most forms of tourism are fashioned by culturally coded attempts to escape from the everyday (Edensor, 2007). Today, each of us is a potential tourist and part of the problem of fostering unsustainable tourist practices. For different reasons, purposes, curiosities or necessities, we exercise our mobility. In the early 2000s, travel and tourism scholars sought to place ‘mobility at the heart of our understanding of tourism’ (Hall, 2005, p. 134; Hannam, 2008). The rise of the new mobilities paradigm helps us understand global tourism in the context of other social and spatial travel processes while paying attention to the production and consumption patterns of both tourists and residents, all influenced by similar (and also opposite) gazes and performances in different places (Sheller and Urry, 2004; Adey, 2017). The problematic relationship between tourists and hosts – and the overlap between the two – has generated recent waves of anti-tourism protests in enduringly popular European cities such as Venice, Barcelona, Amsterdam, Rome and Dubrovnik (Butler, 1980; Russo, 2002; Novy, 2016; Gerritsma and Vork, 2017), as well as in other parts of the world such as Central America (Cañada, 2010). The debate concerning the backlash of social movements against the pressure of tourism is not something new, as noticed by Milano (2018, p. 552) – instead, it may be more appropriate to talk about an old debate which has acquired new configurations.

A tourist’s mood can be seen as a moment of withdrawal from the everyday routine, which contrasts with local residents’ lifestyles, yet a mood compelled by the search for new and authentic experiences (MacCannell, 1999). One of the most popular slogans reflecting the search for authenticity is ‘live like a local’, popularized by the most prominent peer-to-peer short-term holiday rentals company, Airbnb. This has changed to ‘belong anywhere’, questioning even further the assumption that tourism is simply a consequence of ‘host–guest interactions’. Tourism is frequently acclaimed as one of the world’s largest and most pervasive industries and, as any other industry, has been demonstrated to have both positive and negative effects at destinations and on those who live there (World Travel & Tourism Council, 2018).

It is arguable that the sustainability of tourism across Europe remains elusive, with the industry not fully comprehending how to achieve desirable sustainability goals (Cheer and Lew, 2017). Tourism has a Janus-faced character (Sanchez and Adams, 2008); indeed, for a lot of destinations, tourism has become the most important economic development vehicle, yet it is also the most problematic and complex to tackle and come to terms with. Venice is evidence of this and is undoubtedly a global icon attracting millions of tourists annually, with a local economy highly dependent on tourism, and overtourism symptoms that are near impossible to reconcile.

In this chapter we examine the contemporary touristification of Venice, first through a ‘panoramic’ overview, and then through a deeper analysis of the spatial impacts of tourism development over the last decade. According to Zanetto (1986), tourism has been a central part of Venetian culture and society since at least the 18th century. Today, however, there is ample evidence to suggest that tourism has taken over the historical city of Venice. Our principal aim is to assess a series of warning signs (e.g. depopulation, uncontrollable and overwhelming tourist flows, the rise of day-trippers, decline in the hospitality sector, intensification of low-cost airline activity, exponential growth of international cruise ships and explosions in the growth of peer-to-peer short-term holiday rentals platforms) associated with overtourism.

The deep analysis demonstrates how the impacts of overtourism stretch far beyond dimensions of local quality of life, affecting and irreversibly changing the balance of the city’s economic landscape and leading to transformation of its fundamental geography. This analysis illustrates an alarming picture of Venice where, for example, the number of residents in the city is now equivalent to the number of beds for tourists. Finally, we propose a list of possible over-tourism indicators that could further contribute to the overtourism debates, and stimulate new areas of inquiry that may be useful in explaining the reasons for the development and intensification of anti-tourist sentiments. The negative local feelings are shared not only by residents, but also by regular city users (i.e. workers and students). In recent years, the public sector has been expected to manage tourist flows and support both residents and tourists in their exchange for a more mutually beneficial authentic experience.

1.2 Research Context: Venice, an Overtourism Icon

In 1996, Van der Borg et al. (1996, p. 314) defined Venice as ‘the city that most clearly represents what the term touristification means for an urban area’. Venice has since become one of the most cited cases for describing the growing global problem of overtourism. One of the key issues that characterizes the phenomenon of overtourism in the case of Venice is the city’s gradually declining population, as described in the documentary film The Venice Syndrome (Pichler and Tielsch, 2012), and a hotly contested matter central to the angst of local social movements (Quinn, 2007; Cavallo, 2016; Minoia, 2017). For instance, when the population dipped below 60,000 in 2008, a group of residents organized a mock ‘funeral’ for the city. Before the funeral, in Campo San Bartolomeo (a stone’s throw away from the Rialto Bridge), a counter that indicates in real time the number of residents in Venice’s historic centre was placed in the window of the Morelli pharmacy. The counter was inaugurated on 21 March 2008 and, on that day, the LED screen indicated 60,699. In November 2018, this had fallen to 53,135 (Comune di Venezia, 2018a).

Owing to its particular geographical urban characteristics, as well as its physical and cultural attractiveness, Venice is also a classic case of ‘hypertouristification’ (Costa and Marinotti, 2003; Minoia, 2017). In the city, residents have become consumed by the ills brought about by tourism, the local newspapers churn out articles about touristic issues almost on a daily basis and the committees in favour of housing dedicate considerable time and space to the theme. This is reflected in UNESCO’s threats to add Venice to the list of valuable cultural assets at risk, precisely because of the unresolved problems caused by tourism (UNESCO, 2015). In particular, the public demonstration #MiNoVadoVia (I do not go away) was held on the banks of Riva degli Schiavoni on 2 July 2017. This mobilized almost all the city committees, usually known for their bitter disagreements, and in unprecedented fashion united them in protest against out-of-control touristification. #MiNoVadoVia incorporated other similar initiatives and makes explicit reference to the depopulation of the city because of the so-called tourist ‘invasion’. Exactly 1 month after the event, The New York Times published an article titled ‘Venice, invaded by tourists, risks becoming “Disneyland on the Sea”’ (Horowitz, 2017). This is only one of a plethora of articles emphasizing the potentially catastrophic impact of tourism on cities’ residents. What is most compelling, however, is not so much the comparison with Disneyland as a leitmotif already used and heard but, rather, the dramatic impact tourism has had on rapid population decline. The axiomatic equation that represents the Venice situation is that, as the number of tourists continues to rise, this has had a correspondingly inverse impact on the city’s population.

1.3 Venice – Overtourism Warning Signs

To put it simply, in this context ‘overtourism’ defines an occurrence of far too many visitors for a particular destination to absorb over a given period. Indeed, ‘too many’ is a subjective term, and it is best defined in each destination relative to the number of local residents, hosts, business owners and tourists. The reasons behind overtourism in Venice are complex and numerous. Many of the same causal factors in Venice are also found in Barcelona, Reykjavik, Dubrovnik and other popular destination sites (Milano et al., 2018). The impacts of overtourism stretch way beyond quality of life, though. With time, as evidenced in Venice, over...

Table of contents

• Cover
• Half-title Page
• Title Page
• Copyright
• Contents
• Notes on Contributors
• Foreword
• Introduction: Overtourism: An Evolving Phenomenon
• 1 Venice: An Analysis of Tourism Excesses in an Overtourism Icon
• 2 Tourist Gentrification of Retail Shops in Palma (Majorca)
• 3 ‘¿Todos a Galápagos?’ Overtourism in Wilderness Areas of the Global South
• 4 Beyond Overtourism: Studying the Entanglements of Society and Tourism in Iceland
• 5 Responses to Overtourism in Guanacaste (Costa Rica): A Rural Water Conflict Perspective
• 6 Overcrowded Amsterdam: Striving for a Balance Between Trade, Tolerance and Tourism
• 7 Public Policies and Tourist Saturation in the Favelas of Rio de Janeiro
• 8 Short-Term Accommodation and Overtourism in Portuguese Urban Centres
• 9 My Overloved Town: The Challenges of Growing Up in a Small Coastal Tourist Destination (Byron Bay, Australia)
• 10 Greenland’s Tourism Policy Making and the Risk of Overtourism
• Afterword: Over Overtourism or Just the Beginning?
• Index
• Backcover