Chapter 1
The role of the GPN: Political, professional and economic drivers
Deborah Duncan
Introduction
In all corners of the NHS, work is currently being undertaken to develop a robust competency framework for both treatment room nurses and general practice nurses. This chapter looks at how the GPN role has changed since the 1960s.
Historically, GPNs contributed to the delivery of the GP contract to the whole spectrum of the practice population. Now GPNs work as part of a multi-disciplinary team (MDT) within GP surgeries, assessing, screening and treating patients of all ages. They also offer health promotion advice in areas such as contraception, weight loss, smoking cessation and travel health. Their role now also embraces expertise in long-term conditions (LTCs), preventative services, sexual health and advanced clinical skills (QNI 2015). There is a specific skill set to manage uncertainty and risk when supporting people who may have undifferentiated diagnoses. All this has to be delivered according to guidelines and protocols, adhering to the Quality Outcomes Framework (QOF) within general practice. Nurses will be central to the delivery of the new care model set out in the NHSâ Five Years Forward View (NHS 2014) so that they can meet the needs of an ageing population, many of whom have comorbidities and long-term conditions (Goodwin et al. 2011).
In 1948, when the NHS was created, GPNs were responsible for all personal medical care. They became the gateway for individuals to access hospitals, specialist care and social care. In the early days of the NHS there were few explicit standards for general practice, and few incentives for medical professionals to take on the GP role (Godwin et al. 2011). There was also a rapidly growing demand for services (Collings 1950). Many GP practices employed nurses to support them with these challenges.
The 1960s to the 1980s
The role of the GPN then saw significant financial support and development in the 1960s. The first contract between General Practitioners (GPs) and the NHS was formalised in 1966 and this covered funding for ancillary staff, including nurses (QNI 2015). Initially, nursing staff were mainly working as treatment room nurses (Cartwright & Scott 1961). The 1966 contract for GPs included additional payments to cover the costs of practice staff and premises as well as the responsibility of providing 24-hour care, 365 days a year. However, this still did not really affect the work of the GPN.
In 1972 the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) was created, giving GPs their own official representative body for the first time. In 1976 a three-year postgraduate training programme became mandatory for GPs. Finally, in 1978, the WHOâs Alma Ata Declaration on Primary Health meant that disease prevention and health promotion increasingly started to be seen as a central part of general practice. GP practices recruiting GPNs would advertise these posts indicating that the role included a significant long-term care component, disease prevention and health promotion, and some treatment room work (such as dressings). They also offered GPNs some support to gain competencies for cervical smears, travel health and child immunisations (While & Webley-Brown 2017). However, many GPNs did not feel they received the training they were promised (While & Webley-Brown 2017).
In the 1980s the RCGP Quality Initiative was launched, in response to increasing evidence of variation in clinical practice. Early attempts to measure quality in primary care and provide incentives for improvement were met with increasing resistance. There was no significant change for GPNs until the early 1990s and the introduction of the âinternal marketâ (the GP fundholding system). At this point, for the first time, GPs were given budgets to commission services for their local populations. The new GP contract included chronic disease clinics and incentives to meet the population target rates for vaccinations and cervical screening. GPs therefore responded by employing nurses to provide these services (McGee & Castledine 1999). By the time this system was disbanded by the Labour government in 1998, only 33 per cent of practices were participating.
This change did, however, have a huge impact on the role of the GPN because general practice was now being seen as less curative and reactive and more preventive and proactive. The management of long-term conditions and health promotion was largely delegated to GPNs and, as a result, the numbers of nurses employed increased, as did the need for further specialised education. Research showed that, although nurses needed longer consultations for these patients, they did provide effective care (Laurant et al. 2005, Woodroffe 2006). A later Cochrane review (comparing GP and GPN consultations) showed that there were no consistent differences in problem recognition, examination, prescribing, and referral or diagnostic test rates or patient satisfaction (Wilson et al. 2006). This extended role became an important consideration when employing new staff. GPNs were also shown to offer effective services for patients with minor illnesses or ailments and those requiring same-day appointments (Shum et al. 2000).
Also, in the 1990s the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) Practice Nurse Forum lobbied for specialist practitioner recognition from the United Kingdom Central Council. This was achieved in 1994 (UKCC 1994) although there was not yet a recognised qualification.
Changes from 2000 to 2010
In 2004 the General Medical Services (GMS) contract was renewed and the GMS introduced the Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF), a voluntary scheme giving GPs an incentive to provide services in addition to their core essential services. For the first time, GPs began to employ healthcare support workers or healthcare assistants (HCAs) in order to release the GPNs to focus on this specialised work. HCAs were shown to make an increasingly useful contribution to the skill mix in general practice (Bosley & Dale 2008). Not only was the HCA role reviewed, but there was a continuing incentive to educate and encourage the GPN in general practice (Sibbald, Laurant et al. 2006). However, it can be difficult for nurses to fulfil such a varied role when they come from a piecemeal educational background.
Alongside the changes in the contractual arrangements with general practice, there was the 2000 NHS Plan which stated that âthe future of the NHS Plan rests on the strength of its primary care servicesâ and this required the introduction of new models of general practice (DH 2000). In 2005 the Chief Nursing Officer introduced the Liberating the Talents paper which set out 10 key roles for nurses in extending and advancing their clinical roles (DH 2005). The Darzi review also encouraged the use of quality indicators at all levels in the NHS, including general practice (DH 2008). The response was the establishment of stronger regulatory and governance mechanisms, including annual appraisals for GPNs.
Changes from 2010 onwards
Within a decade, following the change from a Labour to a Conservative government, the primary care landscape had changed again â with the arrival of new Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs). Health Education England (HEE) and the Local Education and Training Boards (LETBs) were also formed (DH 2012a, 2012b). The Health and Social Care Act (2012) introduced comprehensive changes to the way the NHS operates, as the aim was to see more than 80,000 people with complex needs receiving community-based, GP-led, personalised care by 2014 (DH 2012b).
GPs were expected to take a lead role in independent CCGs and have greater influence over the design and delivery of local healthcare services, which included 60 per cent of the ÂŁ110 billion NHS budget. The central tenet of the reforms was âno decision about me without meâ which means increasing choice and service integration, delivering care closer to home and highlighting patient involvement. This required better communication between GP practices and other services such as community nursing services, A&E, ambulance services, care homes, and mental health and social care teams (DH 2012b).
The principle that âAll UK residents are entitled by law to access primary care services, which are free at the point of needâ was key to the establishment of the NHS in 1948 and was restated in the 2012 NHS Constitution for England (DH 2012c). Again, the workload of the nursing team increased in response to these demands. Nurses were seen to play a greater role in general practice, with the number of full-time equivalent nurses employed in general practice rising by 37 per cent between 1999 and 2006 to 14,616 (Goodwin et al. 2011, p. 1).
Patientsâ have also become more demanding in terms of what they expect from general practice; they want greater responsiveness from GP practices, better coordination of services and a focus on health promotion (RCGP 2007). These changing demands have led to the employment of more GPNs and HCAs. This is reflected in the fact that, between 1995 and 2008, the proportion of general practice consultations undertaken by nurses increased by 14 per cent (Hippisley Cox & Vinogradova 2009).
In 2015, in a response aimed at standardising some aspects of the nursing team training, the framework for a Care Certificate was published by Health Education England (HEE) to replace the National Minimum Training Standards (NMTS) and the Common Induction Standards (CIS) that had historically provided the framework for healthcare assistants working within health and social care.
The Five Year Forward plan from NHS England (2016) makes a variety of suggestions to respond to ever-changing demands in general practice. One such suggestion is that CCGs, local authorities and NHS England will be able to pool budgets to jointly commission expanded services, including the hiring of additional nurses in GP settings to provide a coordination role for patients with long-term conditions (The Kingâs Fund 2015). It is also suggested that a GPN development strategy should include improving training capacity in general practice, increasing the number of preregistration nurse placements, improving retention of the existing nursing workforce and supporting practice nurses to return to work (NHS England 2016).
Such a radical plan will require the investment of an additional 15 million pounds and a review of the previous piecemeal GPN training (NHS England 2016). This plan recognises the problems that will potentially occur within the next five years and mirrors the 2015 Queenâs Nursing Institute report which suggested that 33.4 per cent of the GPN workforce will be due to retire by 2020 (Bradby & McCallum 2015).
The Queenâs Nursing Institute is a registered charity established in 1887. It is dedicated to improving the nursing care of people in the home and community. The institute has an established national network of Queenâs Nurses, who are committed to the highest standards of care and who lead and inspire others. The institute also offers education grants to fund nurses to improve patient care by supporting them to develop their skills through leadership and training programmes, publishing research, influencing government, policy makers and employers, and campaigning for investment in high-quality community nursing services.
For more information go to https://www.qni.org.uk
Box 1.1: The Queenâs Nursing Institute
...