Appendix 1
Design charts for rectangular and barbell section walls
A1.1 INTRODUCTION
Design charts (Figures A1.1–A1.13) were developed to provide accurate estimates of nominal flexural strength and yield curvature, for materials having actual strengths equal to the nominal values identified. The basis used to derive the charts is described in Section A1.2, while the application of the charts for use with expected material properties is described in Section A1.3.
A1.2 ASSUMPTIONS USED IN DEVELOPING DESIGN CHARTS
Concrete and steel strengths were taken equal to their nominal values (, and fy = 60 ksi), respectively. Concrete was assumed to have zero tensile capacity; reinforcing steel was modeled as elastic-plastic. Section analyses follow ACI 318 requirements; constitutive relationships, strain compatibility, and equilibrium were satisfied, assuming plane sections remain plane. Nominal flexural strength, Mn, was determined per ACI 318 at an extreme fiber strain of 0.003.
In most of the cases considered, the curvature corresponding to first yield, was taken equal to the curvature at the instant in the plane sections analysis that the extreme tension reinforcement reached a strain of εy (= fy/Es). At this curvature the extreme concrete fiber stress was less than . In some cases with relatively high levels of axial load and/or high reinforcement ratios, the steel would remain elastic while the concrete reached its strength. In these cases, the “yield” curvature was defined as that corresponding to the extreme concrete fiber reaching a stress of . Thus, the curvature at first yield was defined by the first event to occur: the extreme tensile reinforcement reaching fy or the extreme concrete fiber reaching . The corresponding moment was termed the yield moment .
The effective yield curvature, ϕy, for the cross section was determined by extrapolating the first yield value to the point where the moment reaches the nominal strength level:
where Mn = moment resistance corresponding to a concrete strain of 0.003 at the extreme compression fiber and = moment resistance when longitudinal boundary reinforcement strain reaches (or where the extreme concrete fiber reaches ).
The effective yield curvatures plotted below are consistent with the observations of Paulay (2002), who suggested effective yield curvatures of 1.8εy/lw and 2.0εy/lw for rectangular section walls with and without longitudinal boundary (end) reinforcement, respectively. These two values correspond to 0.0037/lw and 0.0041/lw, respectively, for Grade 60 reinforcement. Paulay also suggested effective yield curvatures for other cross sections: 2.0εy/lw for I- and C-shaped sections, and 1.4εy/lw for T-shaped sections in which the flange is in compression and 1.8εy/lw for T-shaped sections in which the flange in tension.
The parametric analyses are based on lumping the longitudinal boundary reinforcement As = ρ(2dʹtw) at a distance dʹ from the edge of a rectangular section, and As = ρ(tftw) at the ce...