To Tell the Truth
She wasnât studying. Studying was what she was supposed to be doing, what she intended to do, what she was going to start doing any minute now. First, though, she had to wait for the album to finishâthe new Talking Heads, with its bass-heavy rendition of âTake Me to the River,â which she couldnât get enough ofâand click through all the channels on the TV while absorbing her daily dose of disodium guanylate, autolyzed yeast extract and rendered chicken fat in her Top Ramen, which was about the only thing she was eating lately. It was cheap and fast and that was all that mattered. Not that she was happy about itâshe knew she had to start eating better, but she hadnât actually cooked anything even remotely healthy for weeks, and then it was only pasta with a red sauce out of a jar and a wedge of iceberg lettuce on the side and maybe a pickle or two. Were pickles healthy? They prevented scurvy, sheâd read that somewhere. Columbus had stocked them on the Niña, the Pinta and the Santa Maria for that purpose, but then she wasnât on a ship at sea but in her efficiency apartment in university housing, and the problem was time. And will. Work, school, work, schoolâit was as if she were on a stationary bicycle pedaling furiously, going nowhere.
The Top Ramen (Lime Shrimp) was boiling on the stove. Her books were spread out on the old steamer trunk from Goodwill she used as a coffee table. She was going to eat and study at the same time, then maybe go for a walk around the block and come back and study till it was time to go to bed, which lately had been anywhere from eleven to two, depending on how bored she was and how hopeless the quest for her degree seemed at any given moment. But first she clicked the remote, just to see what was on, and the screen came alive to a scrum of earnest figures in cleats and helmets chasing a little brown ball across an expanse of gleaming grass. She clicked again: sitcom. Again: the news. Once more: game show.
The game show was one she used to watch back at home and as soon as the logo appeared on the screen she felt a quick sharp pang of nostalgia, she and her sister stretched out on the living room rug, doing their homework, their mother in the recliner rattling the cubes in her second or third vodka and soda, one Lark at her lips and the other smoldering in the ashtray. And the show, comforting in its banality, everything preordained and usual, the panel of celebrities nobody had ever heard of apart from the de facto evidenceâKitty Carlisleâstraining to be witty and urbane, middle Americaâs entrĂ©e into a world of martinis and limos and lathered-on makeup. Three men materialized out of the shadows to introduce themselves, each claiming to be Guy Schermerhornâtwo older and wearing glasses, one younger and notâbefore taking their seats, stage right, at the desk reserved for the contestants. The celebrity panel was seated across from them, stage left, and it was their task to determine which two were the imposters and which the original, the one telling the truth.
She didnât have time for this, but then she did. Because the affidavit the host read out wasnât the usual sort of thing at allâGuy Schermerhorn wasnât the pedestrian husband of a hypersexualized actress or a race car driver recognizable only with his crash helmet on or the discoverer of a new element for the periodic table, but a researcher who, he claimed, was teaching apes to talk. Sheâd heard about thatâthey were doing it here too, at UCSM, werenât they? And come to think of it, the young guy, the one in the middle, looked familiar, as if sheâd seen him on campus, but whether she had or not, she was sure he was the one telling the truth. The other two might have had more gravitas, but that was only because of the glasses and the age difference, and of course the producers of the show relied upon deception by way of keeping the audience guessing along with the celebrity panel, otherwise no one would have bothered to tune in.
Bill Cullenâhe wore glasses too, the lenses so thick they distorted his eyesâwas up first and he put his question to Guy Schermerhorn Number 1, on the left. âSo what was the first thing the ape said? Iâm guessing it was either âYou got a cigarette?â or âCan you loan me a dime so I can call my lawyer and get out of this joint?ââ
The audience laughed. Guy Schermerhorn Number 1 laughed too and then he composed his face and said, âThey donât actually talkâitâs more like sign language.â
âOh, really?â Bill Cullen leaned into the long desk the panel shared. He was enjoying this, enjoying the opportunity to show off his wit for all those people out there in the living rooms of America and relishing the fact that he was a celebrity and they werenât. âHow do you say âMake mine a martini, straight up, two olives?ââ
Again, the audience laughter. But Guy Schermerhorn Number 1 dodged the question with a quip of his own, as if he were auditioning for a seat on the panel. âWe try to discourage them from drinking,â he said, giving the camera a deadpan look, but the thing was, he didnât attempt any sign language, which to Aimee was a dead giveaway, even if she hadnât already decided on Number 2.
It was Kitty Carlisle now, looking ageless in her midnight-black bouffant, though the flesh at her throat was pulled tight as a string bag. She gave the camera a catty look, then zeroed in on Number 3. âCould you demonstrate something in sign language for usâit is sign language you use, isnât it?â
Number 3 nodded.
âHow about, oh, I donât knowââDo you take your coffee black or with cream and sugar?ââ
The man raised both his hands to the level of his chest and Aimee thought for an instant that sheâd been wrong, that this was the real Guy Schermerhorn, but then, lamely, he dropped them to the desk and said, âWe donât serve them coffee.â
âJangles their nerves?â the host put in, and everybody laughed. He was seated center stage behind his own desk, his bald head flashing under the stage lights. Aimee didnât remember his name, not that it mattered. He was a celebrity too.
Kitty Carlisle couldnât resist the joke. âWhat about Sanka?â she asked of nobody in particularâjust threw it out thereâbefore turning to the contestant in the middle, Guy Schermerhorn Number 2, with a penetrating look. âWhat about you, Number Twoâcan you tell us how to say âHow do you take your coffeeâblack or with cream and sugar?ââ And now a quick aside, eyes on the camera: âI mean, in case we have an ape over for dinner some evening . . .â
Guy Schermerhorn Number 2âhe was the real Guy Schermerhorn, no doubt in Aimeeâs mindâwas in his late twenties or early thirties and he wore his hair long, parted just to the left of center and tucked behind his ears. His eyes jumped and settled and he was instantly, unshakably, calm. He used his fingers only (it was called finger-spelling, as she was later to learn), moving them so quickly and adeptly he might have been a clarinetist running through âFlight of the Bumblebeeâ without benefit of an instrument.
Kitty Carlisle said, âThat was either the most amazing thing weâve seen on this showâor pure gibberish. Thatâs not gibberish, is it, Number Two?â
Number 2 shook his head no, then the other two panelists got their chance to quiz the three men, though it was really no contest after that, and there were three votes for Guy Schermerhorn Number 2 against a sole vote for Number 1 (Bill Cullen) and none for Number 3. But wait, wait, it wasnât over yetâinstead of having the real Guy Schermerhorn stand up and take his bow, there was a surprise . . .
The backstage curtains parted and out came a chimpanzee in diapers and a polo shirt with the sleeves cut off and he wasnât walking on his knuckles but standing on two feet and swaying side to side in the kind of gait youâd expect from a toddler, which, as it turned out, was what he was. He looked out at the crowd, which had sent up a whoop when he appeared, then at the panel and the three contestants, before letting out a low hoot and scampering across the floorâknuckles nowâand launching himself over the low desk where the contestants were seated to land squarely in the lap of the man in the middle, as if there had ever been any doubt. But he didnât simply land thereâhe embraced Guy Schermerhorn like a lover, kissing him on the lips and then swiveling his head around to stare into the camera as if this was all in a dayâs work. His hands were moving now, first for the camera, then for Guy Schermerhorn, who returned the gesture, or a different gesture, as if he understood what the chimp was saying and the chimp understood himâas if they were truly communicating, in real time, while the whole nation looked on.
The host, his grin as wide as the screen, couldnât resist putting one more question to the man with the ape in his lap: âWhat did he just say?â
âHe said he wants a cheeseburger.â
The audience roared.
âDoes he have a name?â the host wanted to know, riding with it now, the grin ironed to his face. The camera panned over the audience, a sea of shining eyes and open mouths, then swung back to Guy Schermerhorn.
Guy Schermerhorn spoke aloud as he signed the question to the chimp: âWhat is your name?â
The chimpâhe was adorable, a big-eared doll come to lifeâmade a rapid gesture with one hand before flicking the back of his ear as if shooing a fly, and Guy Schermerhorn provided the translation. âHis nameâs Sam.â
But the chimpâSamâwasnât done yet. He interjected a further comment, either in correction or addition, the gestures so rapid you couldnât follow them till Guy Schermerhorn reprised them in a slowed-down version. âAnd heâs askingâârunning through the gestures now, index finger and thumb to the side of his cheek, a finger touched to his chest and then his hand pushed out in front of him in an undulating motionâââWhen can I go home?ââ A pause, then the real and authentic Guy Schermerhorn spun out one more sign, both palms sliding together in a horizontal clasp: âTo bed.â
Behind her, on the stove, the Top Ramen was boiling over. There was a hiss of vaporizing liquid, followed by the sharp tang of incinerated Lime Shrimp flavoring, and then she was up off the couch and lifting the pot from the burner while the TV audience clapped and whistled and Guy Schermerhorn took the chimp by the hand and led him across the stage and back through the curtains. Sheâd been lost there a moment, gone deepâit was as if a door that had been closed all her life had suddenly swung open. This little creature with the articulate fingers and watchful eyes had not only expressed desireâto have a cheeseburgerâbut heâd conceptualized the future and envisioned a place beyond his immediate surroundings, which animals werenât supposed to be able to do. Sheâd seen it with her own eyes. Unless, of course, it was some sort of trick. Unless heâd just been aping what his trainer had taught him.
But what if he wasnât? Scientists were involved, werenât they? Wasnât Guy Schermerhorn a scientist? And what if it really was possible to speak to the members of another speciesâto converse with them, not just give commands or coach them in the way people coached parrots to regurgitate what theyâd been taught to say? Or dogs. Good boy, roll over, doggie want a treat? It wouldnât be like that. It would be a two-way conversation, a sharing of thoughts on the deepest level. People talked about life on other planets, but this was right here in front of us, a whole other consciousness just waiting to be unlocked. Did apes have God? Did they have souls? Did they know about death and redemption? About Jesus? About prayer? The economy, rockets, space? Did they miss the jungle? Did they even know what the jungle was? What about the collective unconsciousâdid it extend to apes? Did they dream? Make wishes? Hope for the future?
She didnât know, and it probably was just some trick, but when she went to bed that nightânot at one but earlier, much earlier, her books left scattered across the table and the paper for her psych class barely begun, let alone finished, typed and proofreadâshe closed her eyes and saw herself in Guy Schermerhornâs place, strolling across the set of To Tell the Truth and through the pleated curtains, hand-in-hand with this little creature with the big ears and clownish gait and the eyes that said, Here I am, come and get me.
She didnât believe in karma or serendipity or whatever you wanted to call it and she wasnât superstitious, or not particularly. She was a practicing Catholic, though admittedly she could have gone to mass more often, and at the same time, whether it was conceptually incompatible or not, she believed in the observable truths of the sciences. Still, there was coincidence, there was dĂ©jĂ vu and synchronicity and the revolving notion that we never fully inhabit our bodies, all of which hit her smack in the face when she stepped into the psych building two days later to beg Professor Lindelof for an extension and encountered Guy Schermerhornâs face staring out at her from a newspaper article tacked to the bulletin board in the hallway. He was right there, front and center, the little ape in his lap, in what was obviously a still from the television show. The headline read, âUCSM Professor on National TV.â
So she had seen him on campus, after all. She tried to picture the circumstances, the when and where of itâno doubt it was right here in this very building or the student union maybe, or the libraryâbut it wasnât working. She didnât even know what color hair he had, though it seemed light, maybe even blond, on TV and in the newspaper photograph, which unfortunately was in black and white. Or how tall he was or whether he dressed in suit and tie or jeans and a flannel shirt like Dr. Lindelof. Her first impulse was to slip the article into her purse so she could go off somewhere and read it in private, but there were people all around her, voices swelling and clattering, the whole building thundering in her ears with the blunt force of what was happening to her, which went beyond coincidence, way beyond.
She stood there in the crowded hallway, feeling weightless and adrift, scanning the article and hoping no one was watching her, though what would it matter if they were? She was a student reading an item on a bulletin board, that was all, and wasnât that what bulletin boards were for? The article said that Dr. Schermerhorn was an associate professor of psychology, specializing in comparative psychology, and that he was a protĂ©gĂ© of Dr. Donald Moncrief of Davenport University, in Iowa, whoâd pioneered the cross-fostering of chimpanzees in human home environments by way of studying comparative development and language acquisition. Dr. Schermerhorn was one of only six researchers handpicked by Dr. Moncrief to participate in the program nationwide and he was quoted as saying that heâd accepted the invitation from the popular syndicated television show in order to raise awareness of the researchâand funding for UCSMâs own fledgling program in primate behavior.
âWhoa, lookâthe monkey prof. Can you believe it? He was just on TV.â
Two girls had crowded in beside her. The nearest one (bad skin, dog collar, coppery hair cut close to her scalp) she recog...