Section IV
Physical Evidence at Crime Scenes
Outline
Exercise K Physical Searches
Exercise L Visualization and Enhancement: Lighting Aids
Exercise M Visualization and Enhancement: Biological Evidence
Exercise N Visualization and Enhancement: Chemical Evidence
Exercise O Visualization and Enhancement: Combination Methods
Exercise P Packaging, Preservation, and Collection of Evidence
Exercise K
Physical Searches
Exercises to illustrate the common physical searching techniques.
Outline
Objectives of a Crime Scene Search
General Concepts of Crime Scene Searches
Crime Scene Search Patterns
1. Link Method
2. Line (STRIP) Method
3. Grid Method
4. Zone Method
5. Wheel/Ray Method
6. Spiral Method
Laboratory Data Sheet
Discussion Questions
Objective
To practice geometric search patterns commonly used to intensively search at crime scenes.
Physical evidence obtained from the crime scene contributes greatly to the successful outcome of the case investigation. Although it is theoretically possible that a perfect crime has been committed with the perpetrator leaving minimal physical evidence, it is more likely that the critical evidence was never found. The other tasks performed at a crime scene can be learned, but the simple task of finding that critical evidence must never be the failed task of the crime scene investigation. The successful search for evidence will only occur when crime scene investigators understand the objectiveness of a crime scene search and rely on a systematic, structured search process.
Objectives of a Crime Scene Search
The goal of a crime scene search is to locate all potentially relevant and meaningful physical evidence that could be used to link or exonerate a suspect, victim, or witness to a crime. A seasoned crime scene investigator will possess good instincts as to where the relevant evidence will likely be located. Yet once again, there is the inevitable reality; not all evidence can nor will be located by relying on normal expectations. The best method is a systematic and structured basic approach. Underlying the search process are two general issues: Where should you look for the evidence, and how should you actually conduct the search process?
General Concepts of Crime Scene Searches
Although the preliminary scene survey provides the investigators with some idea as to evidence at the crime scene, to search a crime scene properly for physical evidence it is necessary to view the crime scene in its entirety and not just from the perspective of evidence collection. To accomplish this task, it is useful to examine areas which you normally do not examine. Also, look for evidence from different vantage points, for example, at floor level and at an elevated level. It is extremely important to be cautious and take the time necessary for a methodical, systematic search. This approach ensures that critical evidence will not be damaged or overlooked. Also, look for what is not present or what is missing from the scene.
Although there are numerous exceptions, specific crimes regularly generate different kinds of physical evidence. Excellent and productive crime scene searches are based on logic and an analytical approach to the particular scene. Although there is an inherent danger of jumping to conclusions and losing objectivity, it is most beneficial to logically deduce the types of evidence expected and potential locations of that evidence based upon the general type of crime committed (see Figure K.1).
FIGURE K.1 Disappearing bloody footwear impressions do not mean that the source is flying away (Courtesy of Allison Parrott)
Crime Scene Search Patterns
Crime scene search patterns are varied, are outwardly different in style and application, and provide a structure and organization to ensure that no physical evidence is missed at the crime scene. There is no single correct search method for a specific type of crime scene. Most of the basic search patterns employ a geometric pattern (see Figure K.2). The six basic search patterns are the line, grid, spiral, ray, zone, and link methods. If there is any doubt that some evidence may have been overlooked, then an easy-to-use, basic search method should be employed. Note that some search methods are better suited for outdoor scenes, whereas others work best for indoor crime scenes. Of course, any physical evidence found must be immediately documented using the techniques discussed in earlier exercises.
FIGURE K.2 Six geometric search patterns
1 Link Method
The link method is a productive and common approach for crime scene searches. This method is based on the four-way linkage theory, seeking to find associations between the scene, victim, suspect, and physical evidence. It is a systematic and logical method of gathering physical evidence that can be linked to a particular crime or activity. Although this method is not a geometric pattern or easily definable, it is nonetheless a systematic approach. For example, a victim with a gunshot wound leads to a firearm, a projectile, casings, gunshot residue, etc. The linkages are applications of common logic.
2 Line (STRIP) Method
Outdoor crime scenes can be large in scope and difficult to search because of vegetation, topography, water, and area to cover. One of the easiest patterns to employ that is still very effective is the line method. This geometric pattern involves the establishing of a series of lines or strips in the scene. Members of the search team are arranged at regular intervals, usually armās length, and proceed to search ...