Summary
On November 14, 1959, the members of the Clutter family are living out an ordinary autumn Saturday on River Valley Farm, unaware that it will be their last. Herb Clutter, the family patriarch, awakens at seven and eats a light breakfast before taking a walk on his farm. Later in the morning, he drives out to Garden City, Kansas, where he leads a meeting of the Finney County 4-H Club.
Mr. Clutterâs only son, fifteen-year-old Kenyon Clutter, accompanies his father to the 4-H meeting and spends the rest of his afternoon varnishing a mahogany hope chest he made as a wedding present for his older sister Beverly. (The two eldest Clutter children no longer live at home: Eveanna, married, lives in Illinois, while Beverly is studying to be a nurse in Kansas City.)
Nancy Clutter, the sixteen-year-old âtown darling,â flits between several engagements: she chats with her close friend Sue Kidwell on the phone, teaches a neighbor girl how to bake a cherry pie, helps another local girl with a trumpet solo, and runs several errands for her mother, Bonnie Clutter, who has only recently returned from a two-week stay in a psychiatric hospital. Mrs. Clutter rises briefly, but soon returns to bed.
Later that afternoon, Mr. Clutter purchases a $40,000 life insurance policy; after dinner, Nancyâs boyfriend, Bobby Rupp, comes over to watch television. He leaves around ten oâclock with plans to see Nancy again the next day.
Meanwhile, a black 1949 Chevrolet leaves Olathe, Kansas, around three oâclock and drives toward Holcomb, four hundred miles away. Driver and passenger are Richard Hickock and Perry Smith, two ex-convicts who celled together at the Kansas State Penitentiary in Lansing.
The two men talk; Perry plays his guitar. They stop in Emporia, Kansas, where they purchase a pair of rubber gloves and a roll of white nylon rope; they also try and fail to buy black nylon stockings. They eat dinner in Great Bend, and drive on into Holcomb as a full moon rises over the prairie.
The Clutters, devout Methodists, often drive a young friend, Nancy Ewalt, to Sunday church services in Garden Cityâbut on Sunday, November 15, 1959, the Clutter family does not seem to be awake when Nancy Ewalt arrives at their door. Nancy Ewalt and her father drive to the home of Sue Kidwell, to ask if she knows where the family might be. Sue doesnât know. They go back to the Clutter house and the two girls go inside.
They run out screaming. Nancy Clutter is dead.
Later, the sheriff, along with a high school teacher, a deputy, and Mr. Ewalt, discover the bodies of the other three family members. Mrs. Clutter, like Nancy, had been bound, hand and foot, with nylon rope and killed with a shotgun blast to the head. Kenyon and Mr. Clutter lay dead downstairs: Kenyon on the couch, bound and shot like his mother and sister, and Mr. Clutter in the furnace room, with his throat cut and a bullet wound in his head.
The news spreads through Holcomb. Mother Truitt and Mrs. Myrtle Clare, Holcombâs mother-daughter postmistresses, see two ambulances driving toward the Clutter farm. Bobby Rupp learns of his girlfriendâs death when Mr. Ewalt stops by the Rupp farm that afternoon.
National headlines speak of the violent murders, and rumors circulate among friends and acquaintances throughout Holcomb.
In Olathe, Kansas, the two young killers sleep. Perry Smith collapses on a motel bed; Dick Hickock nods off on the couch at his family home. Dick and Perry are exhausted: they have driven more than eight hundred miles in the past twenty-four hours.
Faced with the gruesome murder of a respected family, the townspeople of Holcomb begin to fear and distrust each other. They lock their doors at night. In Hartmanâs CafĂ© and at the post office, wherever people meet, theories and gossip abound. A question reverberates throughout the town: Who killed the Clutters? And another, perhaps more urgent question follows: Why?
Alvin Adams Dewey, the Garden City representative of the Kansas Bureau of Investigation, believes with relative certainty that two suspects, not one, committed the murders. Though clues are sparse at the crime scene, investigators find two footprints: one a bloody Catâs Paw half-sole mark, the other an impression made by a diamond-pattern sole. From a few other cluesâthe pillow beneath Kenyonâs head and the way Nancy was tucked into her bedâDewey concludes that at least one of the killers felt some compassion for the Clutters.
The investigation originally focuses on Bobby Rupp, Nancy Clutterâs boyfriendâhe was the last to see the family alive. Herb Clutter had recently encouraged Nancy to stop seeing Bobby, as the Clutters were Methodist and the Rupps were Catholic. But Bobby Rupp passed a polygraph test, and Dewey believes he is innocent.
Without a single clear suspect, Dewey, along with Kansas Bureau of Invest...