Summary
Letter from the Author
The letterâs date, June 30, 2016, is the very day that Judge Martin Welch overturned Syedâs conviction and ordered a new trial. The ruling came after Syed spent 17 years in prison. The author wrote the letter after writing the book, and it serves as a kind of addendum to the events covered therein.
Introduction
On Friday, February 25, 2000, Rabia Chaudry is in a courtroom in Baltimore, Maryland, with Syedâs family to hear the juryâs verdict in his first-degree murder case. The jury finds him guilty on all charges: first-degree murder of Lee, kidnapping by fraud, robbery, and false imprisonment.
The book features facsimiles of many original documents, including Syedâs letters and other writings, entries from Leeâs diary, and police files. In Syedâs first letter to Sarah Koenig, dated October 10, 2013, he professes his innocence.
Chapter 1. Star-Crossed Lovers
Lee and Syed go to the junior prom in 1998 and quickly begin an intense courtship, one that requires both, but especially Syed, to sneak around behind their parentsâ backs. The Syeds, Rahman and Shamim, are devout Pashtun Muslims from Pakistan who frown upon western pastimes like television watching. They do not believe their children should be dating. Syedâs parents show up at that fallâs homecoming dance and bring him home.
Lee worries about pushing Syed into a crisis of faith, and after homecoming, she breaks things off, only to reunite with him soon after. However, by December, Lee has fallen for coworker from LensCrafters Don Clinedinst and calls it quits with Syed for the final time. While a note from Lee to Syed shows that Syed takes it hard at first, the two remain friends. Syed contends that the breakup was not acrimonious. In fact, he meets the new boyfriend when Lee calls Syed for help after a minor car accident. Everything is friendly between the would-be rivals for Leeâs affections. And soon Syed is interested in a new girl, Nisha Tanna, with whom he spends New Yearâs Eve.
Chapter 2. Vanished: Missing Hae
Leeâs parents call the police after she had been missing for only a few hours. The search begins at 6:00 p.m. on January 13, when the police arrive at Leeâs home and begin calling her friends. They immediately reach Syed on his cell phone but cannot get ahold of Clinedinst until the early morning hours of January 14. Nobody, including Leeâs former and current suitors, knows where she is.
The police begin their investigation with a mistake. Leeâs car is missing and investigators do not immediately enter the vehicle information into the National Crime database. Finally, local police are given the license plate and description of Leeâs car and begin searching.
After Lee goes missing, her uncle hires the Enehey Groupâs Mandy Johnson to investigate and report the findings to the Baltimore Police Department. The Enehey Group is an investigative research agency that claims to use advanced technology and expertise to gather a wide range of information, from espionage to psychological profiling, from historical background research to software design. Enehey Group often works on a confidential basis with law enforcement agencies. The author questions Mandy Johnsonâs credibility on Muslim culture.
On January 25, 1999, Detective Joe OâShea officially interviews Syed. During Syedâs conversations with detectives, he gives inconsistent answers as to whether he asked Lee for a ride after school on January 13. Usually, he would have no need for a ride since he had his own car. However, Syed lent his car to his friendâand pot dealerâJay Wilds that afternoon. This will be a problem for Syed as the case progresses.
Chapter 3. A Body
Off the road and hidden in bushes in Baltimoreâs Leakin Park on February 9, 1999, a man named Alonzo Sellers finds the partially buried body of a young woman. The victim, who shows evidence of blunt force trauma and strangulation, is Lee. Sellers, whose background includes indecent exposure, fails a lie detector test. A second polygraph clears him.
Detectives pursue a tip from an anonymous âAsian maleâ who claims that Syed and Lee had liaisons in Leakin Park. The tipster also asserts that Syed once declared that if he were to murder his girlfriend, he would drive her car into a lake.
On February 27, Jay Wildsâs friend Jennifer Pusateri informs police that Wilds told her that Syed confessed to the murder. Wilds tells investigators that he saw Leeâs body in Syedâs trunk and helped dispose of evidence. Once Wilds leads detectives to Leeâs car in a local parking lot, Syedâs fate is sealed.
Chapter 4. Living the Lie
Detectives arrest Syed at home. His relatives and community are shocked. As his secret world comes crashing down, many are learning for the first time that he had a girlfriend. A letter from Syed to the author describes wanting to fit in with teenage America, and wanting to please his parents. Like many other Muslim teens, Syed hid his indiscretions from his parents and the Muslim community out of respect, a common theme in Muslim culture that creates a sort of double standard: Sins are more severe when they are exposed.
Chapter 5. Murder in the First
When Syed arrives at the police station, he is read his rights and speaks with detectives without a lawyer present. Once he realize...