RULE 1
TRUST FIRST
IMAGINE WHAT YOUR TEAM COULD achieve if your employees were to bring all of themselvesâtheir skills, their talents, their imagination, their energy, their life experience, and their overall brillianceâto work every day. Think of the limitless potential that you would unleash if every member of your team was free to do their best work and share their best ideas, knowing that you value and respect them as unique individuals determined to leave their stamp on the world. Thatâs the prize thatâs on offer when you trust your team. But only when you fully trust your team.
And thatâs the problem.
Trusting others is dangerous and risky because it leaves you exposed. Your trust can be taken for granted, abused, misused, unappreciated, and exploited. It can leave you looking foolish and naive. It can lead to poor-quality work, missed deadlines, and lost customersâfor which you are ultimately responsibleâreflecting badly on you as a manager and leaving you exposed to criticism from your peers and higher-ups. Or worse.
Itâs not difficult to understand, then, why so many managers traditionally have tried to achieve results by not trusting their employees, telling them everything that they should do rather than allowing them to decide some things for themselves. Itâs a familiar but thankfully fading soundtrack: the inspirational âyour job is to do what I say:â the confidence-building âyou better not mess this up;â and the reassuringly supportive âif you donât hear from me that means youâre doing fine.â
This command-and-control approach leaves nothing to chance, no disappointment, no failures, and no surprises. But thereâs a major downside to that approach. It leaves nothing to chance, no disappointment, no failures, and no surprises! In other words, you get exactly what you ask for: predictably average results but zero discretionary effort. Exactly what any other average manager can achieve.
Thereâs another reason so many managers are hesitant to fully trust their employees: trusting others makes us vulnerable. And vulnerability can be extremely uncomfortable, particularly for those in a leadership role. We know that our teams need us to be strong, and we often assume that to be strong we must never show weakness or vulnerability.
As a manager, it would be wonderful if you could wait until each member of your team has shown themselves to be reliable, truthful, and ableâand then trust them. But it doesnât work that way. For trust to take root, somebody must make the first move, so itâs either them or you. Employees have little reason to take a chance on your trustworthiness and they are not all equally inclined to trust in general. Some of them are willing to trust quickly while others take longer to come around. Although an employeeâs opinion of you is obviously important in their decision to trust you, some of that decision has nothing to do with you and everything to do with the employee concerned.
Robert Hurley, a professor of management at New Yorkâs Fordham University, has identified ten factors that can predict if an individual will choose to trust or distrust another. 7 Five of Hurleyâs factors are worth a closer look here.
To start, an employeeâs attitude toward risk has a big impact on their willingness to trust you, or anyone. Risk seekers trust quickly. They donât spend much time figuring out what might go wrong if they trust you, because they believe that things will probably work out. But employees who are risk averse will be reluctant to place their trust in you unless they feel in control. âNot only do they not trust others,â notes Hurley, âthey donât even trust themselves.â
An employeeâs level of adjustment also affects how long it takes them to build trust. Well-adjusted people tend to trust quicklyâthey are comfortable with themselves and with the world around them, and tend to believe that nothing bad will happen to them. A poorly adjusted employee, on the other hand, tends to see many threats in the world, approaches every situation with an underlying level of anxiety, and will take longer to trust you regardless of any good that you do.
Relative power is the third internal factor in an employeeâs decision to trust. You have the power in the relationship with each of your employees. Thatâs just how it is. Itâs relatively easy for you to place your trust in employees because you hold all the cards. You can sanction them if they violate your trust. But what options do employees have if you betray them? They have no authority to do anything but withdraw their trust and resolve to be wiser in the future. Your employees instinctively understand this vulnerability and so will be less comfortable trusting you.
Another factor relevant to an employeeâs decision to trust is security. In other words, the key question for the employee is, Whatâs at stake? âThe higher the stakes, the less likely people are to trust,â explains Hurley. âIf the answer to the question, âWhatâs the worst that can happen?â isnât that scary, itâs easier to be trustful.â So, for example, employees are more likely to trust you when you are deciding on promotions than they are if you are considering layoffs.
Finally, according to Hurley, how similar you and your employees are also makes a big difference in their decision to trust you. We are all quicker to trust people that we can relate to, and we relate more easily to people âlike us,â people who share our values, interests, and perspective. People that are like you, then, are more likely to trust you. But while you might find it easier to earn the trust of a team built in your image, keep in mind that thereâs an important upside to diversity. McKinsey, the worldwide management consulting firm, reports that organisations with a diverse and inclusive workforce enjoy return on equity 53 percent higher and profit margins 14 percent greater than those of the least diverse companies.8
These five factors show just how challenging it is for employees to trust you and why they are unlikely to make the first move when it comes to building trust between you. They are more likely to wait and make their decision to trust based on how you perform over months or even years. But you donât have that luxury. You need trust if you are to unleash the full potential of your team. So, make the first move. Doing so doesnât make you weak. Your true strength lies in having the courage to show humility, openness, and a willingness to trust first.
Yes, being the first to extend trust is risky; it can go horribly wrong. But not if you go about it correctly. Problems typically arise when you extend blind trust, or when you trust and hope for the best, maybe better described as foolish trust. Thatâs the sort of trust that will get you into trouble every time.
Imagine that your eighteen-year-old son asks for your help learning to drive. You trust him, and with good reason. Heâs a responsible teenager: heâs worked a part-time job for years, takes good care of his siblings, and has always worked hard in school. You toss him the keys, saying, âTake my car, son. I trust you to figure out how it all works. Youâve never let me down before. Enjoy!â Thatâs blind, foolish trust. Although your son has proven to be trustworthy in various situations, he has neither the training nor the competence to suggest that he can be trusted with your car. Your trust is unfair to him, as itâs setting him up to fail. And itâs unfair to you for the same reason.
Trust Rules is about extending intelligent trust: the right amount of trust given to the right person at the right time. For example, assigning a big project to an enthusiastic and capable but relatively new employee. Sharing confidential information about the companyâs performance with your employees. Allowing an employee to sign off on their colleaguesâ expenses when youâre out of the office. Extending intelligent trust is a gradual process in which success breeds success and the inevitable setbacks are minor and controlled. You celebrate success, deal with setbacks, and carry on unfazed.
I opened this chapter by inviting you to imagine what your team could achieve if it could work at its full potential. It may sound fanciful, but it is both realistic and achievable when you fully trust yourself to fully trust your team. The rules in the rest of this book offer specific guidance on how to build trust with your employees. Rule 1, however, is the most important: trust first. Youâre the manager, so thatâs on you.
KEY POINTS
Being the first to trust leaves you exposed and makes you vulnerableâand it also shows your strength.
People tend to trust people who are like them. Itâs tempting to hire employees who are similar to you because they will likely be quicker to trust you. But be careful; you donât want to sacrifice the many benefits that a diverse team brings.
Donât trust your employees blindly. Instead, extend intelligent trustâthe right amount of trust given to the right person at the right time.
RULE 2
LIVE WITH INTEGRITY
LIVING WITH INTEGRITY MEANS BEING true to your word in everything you do. It means that people can trust you because you do what you say. Itâs doing the right thing, even when no one is watching, and even if nobody would ever find out if you were to do the wrong thing. It means that you stand for something, even if you stand to lose everything in the process. In short, living with integrity reveals your true character. As the legendary basketball coach John Wooden said, âBe more concerned with your character than your reputation, because your character is what you really are, while your reputation is merely what others think you are.â
In the workplace, integrity matters because how you conduct yourself with your employees, customers, vendors, and suppliers shows the standard of behaviour you expect from them.
Most people have a strong sense of right and wrong and instinctively know the right thing to do when itâs a simple black-or-white issue, but sometimes struggle when they encounter grey areas and borderline cases. Faced with uncertainty and moral dilemmas, your team will follow your lead. Act with the utmost integrity and youâll inspire your employees to do likewise. But when you compromise your integrity for commercial or personal advantage, you create space for others to do the same. The âright thing to doâ is often also the âhard thing to doâ and thatâs why, without strong leadership, some employees may yield to the temptation to take the path of least resistance.
Of course, you shouldnât do the right thing just to set a good example, or because your employees are watching you. You should do the right thing to show who you are, what you believe in, and the values that matter to you. When you live your values, what you do and what you say are one and the same. Even if you assume that most of your employees would do the right thing regardless of how you conduct yourself, they simply wonât trust you if they donât see you holding yourself to the highest possible ethical standards. They will judge your behavio...