The Economics of Target Balances

From Lehman to Corona

Hans-Werner Sinn

• Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
• Year: 2020
• ISBN:
  9783030501709
• Topic: Business
• Subtopic: Business General
• Index: Business

Target balances are the largest single item in some of the balance sheets of the Eurosystem's national central banks (NCBs), and yet very little is known about them by the general public and even by economists. This book shows that Target balances measure overdraft credits between the NCBs that resemble ordinary fiscal credit and which have grown disproportionately, exceeding one billion euros. There is, however, no parliamentary legitimation for the Target balances. The book sheds light on the economic significance of the balances, questions their limitlessness, and addresses controversial views that have been expressed regarding them. It uses the Target statistics to analyze the course of the euro crisis and the ECB's policy reactions from the time of the Lehman bankruptcy up to the outbreak of the Corona crisis. It analyses the credit risks involved for the Eurosystem and concludes with a reform proposal.

This book will be of interest to non-specialist economists and policy makers.

© The Author(s) 2020

H.-W. SinnThe Economics of Target Balanceshttps://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50170-9_1

Begin Abstract

1. Target: An Obscure Aspect of the Eurosystem

Hans-Werner Sinn¹

(1)

Department of Economics & CESifo, Ludwig Maximilian University, Munich, Bavaria, Germany

Hans-Werner Sinn

Email: [email protected]

Keywords

TargetPayment ordersBalance sheetsEurozone crisis

End Abstract

Target balances result from previous net payment orders fulfilled by the national central banks (NCBs). They constitute claims on, and liabilities with, the Eurosystem and are mostly hidden as “other items” in the respective balance sheets of these NCBs. While the sum of all balances is zero by definition, the positive and negative balances alike have grown throughout the euro crisis reaching values way beyond €1.2 billion, with Germany as the biggest Target creditor and Italy and Spain as the biggest Target debtors. The development of the Target balances mirrors the course of the euro crisis.

1.1 The Meaning of Target Balances

“Target” is the name of an international payment system sustained by the Eurosystem.¹ It derives its meaning from the fact that the Eurosystem is organized in a decentralized manner, consisting of a set of national central banks (NCBs) and the European Central Bank (ECB). The NCBs are owned by the respective nation states and distribute their profits to them, but they carry out the orders of the ECB Council. Target balances measure the sum of net payment orders that have been made between the countries of the Eurozone to buy goods and assets and to repay foreign debt. They are negative for a country that gave these net payment orders and positive for a country whose NCB carried out the orders. The balances are respectively booked as liabilities and assets in the individual NCBs’ balance sheets.

The Target balances were very small before the Lehman crisis, showing slightly negative values for countries like Belgium, Greece, Austria and even Germany, while slightly positive values occurred for countries like France, Italy and Spain. But since the outbreak of this crisis, huge imbalances arose with strongly negative values for Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Ireland and Cyprus (GIPSIC), while Germany, the Netherlands, Luxemburg and Finland showed substantial or even very large positive balances. Figure 1.1 gives an overview of the structure of Target balances by the end of 2019. Note that among the negative balances, the figure includes those of the ECB itself. These balances resulted primarily from net payment orders the ECB made to the NCBs in order to buy assets from their territories. Intra-Eurosystem interest payments on the Target balances that the NCBs pay to one another and that result from the pooling of the NCBs’ seignorage income are also recorded in the Target balances. This issue will be discussed in Chap. 9.

Fig. 1.1

Target balances 2019. (Note: The external countries associated with the Eurozone (Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Sweden) are also allowed to have small positive Target balances. They are not included in this diagram. Source: European Central Bank, Statistical Data Warehouse, ECB/Eurosystem policy and exchange rates, Target balances of participating NCBs)

The overall development of the Target balances until the end of 2019 is shown in Fig. 1.2. The sum of all positive balances which was equal to the absolute sum of all negative balances went way beyond €1000 billion. By the end of 2019, the sum was €1286 billion, where the Bundesbank alone accounted for €895 billion. The Target balances are the largest single items in some of the NCB balance sheets, often hidden under miscellaneous items, and yet, only a few people understand what they mean.

Fig. 1.2

The development of Target balances (absolute sum of negative Target balances). (Note: The graph shows the positive Target balances and the absolute values of their negative counterparts alike, if account is taken of the fact that negative balances may occur not only with individual countries but with the ECB itself while non-euro countries associated with the Eurosystem (Bulgaria, Croatia, Czechia, Denmark, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Sweden) are allowed to participate in the Target system with positive balances. The Target data used in this book refer to end of month. The ECB’s negative balances (€236 billion by the end of 2019) result primarily from the ECB’s participation in asset purchasing programs. Sources: Sinn /Wollmershäuser (2012), until April 2008 on the basis of a calculation using IMF Data, thereafter: European Central Bank, Statistical Data Warehouse, ECB/Eurosystem policy and exchange rates, Target balances of participating NCBs as well as Deutsche Bundesbank, Banca d’Italia, Banco de España, balance sheets)

As this book was completed just a few weeks after the outset of the Corona crisis, a complete set of data showing the effect of that crisis was not yet available when it was due. However, for the Bundesbank, Banco de España and Banca d’Italia the Target data covered in this book extend to March 2020 and thus do include the reactions of the respective balances after the first rapid breakdown of the stock market during the Corona crisis. Chapter 5 will argue that the Corona crisis opens up a new phase in the development of the Target balances, and Chap. 11 will discuss what has happened and might still be happening.

Much light has been shed on the Target balances in recent years, but there is an ongoing controversy about their meaning. Are they a normal implication of a well-functioning monetary system or do they indicate financial stress and problems? Do they involve risks for the creditor countries? Are they perhaps even a time bomb for the Eurozone? Or are they the glue that is keeping everything together? Whatever the appropriate answers to these questions, it seems fair to say that they have not yet been well understood by policy makers and even by many experts in academia and in the financial industry.

This is the rationale for this book: It seeks to give a systematic assessment of the Target phenomenon which may counter distorted narratives influenced by vested political interests. The book aims at addressing most of the controversial questions and views that have been expressed about the Target balances. The interpretation as well as the data and facts presented here are partly new, just because the balances have recently been influenced by new policy decisions. However, the book reflects the author’s and others’ writings on the issue² and it also reveals the general scientific knowledge that has accumulated since the rising balances were made known to the public and the economics discipline in 2011. This book tries to be objective, logical and truthful, but at the same time non-trivial, interesting and understandable to non-specialist economists, politicians and people interested in financial matters.

For politicians, Target balances are unpleasant accompaniments of the Eurosystem and make it difficult for them to offer explanations, because the potential policy implications are disturbing, and also because the issue is difficult in itself. The Target balances are therefore often named “meaningless, irrelevant accounting items”. However, this view is certainly not correct. It conflicts with the fact that the balances are part of a country’s net foreign asset position as published by Eurostat, and their fluctuations enter a country’s official balance of payment statistics as public capital export. Former ECB President Draghi said he observes the Target balances “every day actually, not almost every day!” and warned that countries exiting the Eurozone would have to redeem their Target debt in full.³

1.2 Mirroring the Eurozone Crisis

Some observers see the balances as a mirror of the crisis if not as a kind of fever thermometer. Indeed, it is noteworthy that the rise of the Target balances coincides with the Eurozone crisis, which broke out in 2007/2008. Whether this mirror interpretation is true or ...

Table of contents

• Cover
• Front Matter
• 1. Target: An Obscure Aspect of the Eurosystem
• 2. The Target Credit
• 3. Current Account, Capital Movements and Target Balances
• 4. The Cash Balance
• 5. How the Target Balances Came About: The First Phase of the Crisis
• 6. The Case of Greece
• 7. External and Internal Money
• 8. The QE Program and the Target balances
• 9. The Effective Rate of Interest on Target Balances
• 10. Interest Spreads and Tiering
• 11. The Corona Crisis
• 12. The Risks of Target and Cash Balances
• 13. Conclusions and Policy Recommendations
• Correction to: The Economics of Target Balances
• Back Matter