![Bergson, Complexity and Creative Emergence](https://img.perlego.com/book-covers/3489286/9781137412201_300_450.webp)
This is a test
- English
- ePUB (mobile friendly)
- Available on iOS & Android
eBook - ePub
Bergson, Complexity and Creative Emergence
Book details
Book preview
Table of contents
Citations
About This Book
This is a book about evolution from a post-Darwinian perspective. It recounts the core ideas of French philosopher Henri Bergson and his rediscovery and legacy in the poststructuralist critical philosophies of the 1960s, and explores the confluences of these ideas with those of complexity theory in environmental biology.
Frequently asked questions
At the moment all of our mobile-responsive ePub books are available to download via the app. Most of our PDFs are also available to download and we're working on making the final remaining ones downloadable now. Learn more here.
Both plans give you full access to the library and all of Perlegoâs features. The only differences are the price and subscription period: With the annual plan youâll save around 30% compared to 12 months on the monthly plan.
We are an online textbook subscription service, where you can get access to an entire online library for less than the price of a single book per month. With over 1 million books across 1000+ topics, weâve got you covered! Learn more here.
Look out for the read-aloud symbol on your next book to see if you can listen to it. The read-aloud tool reads text aloud for you, highlighting the text as it is being read. You can pause it, speed it up and slow it down. Learn more here.
Yes, you can access Bergson, Complexity and Creative Emergence by David Kreps in PDF and/or ePUB format, as well as other popular books in Philosophy & Philosophy & Ethics in Science. We have over one million books available in our catalogue for you to explore.
Information
Topic
PhilosophySubtopic
Philosophy & Ethics in Science1
Introduction
This is a book about evolution.
It may seem that the arguments about what evolution is have all been played out â over a hundred years ago â and that Darwinâs version of events is today challenged only by the religiously devout. But the truth is that Darwinâs version of events is itself challenged by the orthodox neo-Darwinism popularised by such figures as Dawkins, and that not only is there a long tradition of other ideas about evolution, there is today a very strong case to suggest that Darwinâs was only part of the story â and not even the most important part at that.
This is a book about two alternatives to orthodox Darwinism that turn out to be both closely related and mutually reinforcing â and which both uphold Darwinâs version of events as a secondary force. One derives from late 19th/early 20th century French philosophy; the other from contemporary complex evolutionary biology. I set out in this book to describe both these alternatives in terms understandable by as wide a range of scholars as I am able: both to inform those aware of philosophy concerning the developments in environmental biology; and, perhaps more importantly, vice versa. In the process I will also need to tell the history of our understanding and use of the term âsystemâ: it turns out that this is crucial to how we understand evolution.
The philosopher who is the focus of our attention is Henri Bergson (1859â1941). Bergsonâs ideas are enjoying something of a revival in various circles. He has, in the past, had many critics; and there remain â in this authorâs eyes, at least â some elements of his work that have not stood the test of time (for example, elements of the second part of his last work, Two Sources of Morality and Religion), and some arguments that remain very controversial, (such as over the relativity of time and space in Duration and Simultaneity). Nonetheless, there have been developments in both philosophy â in particular, poststructuralism â and in scientific endeavour â for example, some of the discoveries of contemporary neuroscience â where Bergsonâs ideas have, despite early criticism, proved far more accurate than his detractorsâ.
Contemporary evolutionary biology has been one of the principle sites for the development of the sciences of complexity, in the latter part of the 20th century. This development was greatly accelerated by the enormous advances in computing in the late 1980s and 1990s, and complexity science has spread to multiple sites and down multiple avenues, with the results disseminated from its multiple sources to equally multiple audiences during the 1990s and the first decade of the 21st century. In evolutionary biology computer models of molecular and biotic networks have given enormous insight into the workings of the natural world.
These advances prove to be a further reason to revisit the ideas of Bergson and see where, in like measure, his early critics may have been mistaken, and some of his primary arguments in fact much more cogent and powerful than at first thought. This book is not my attempt to suggest that âBergson was right all along,â or that âBergson saw it all first.â I shall not, either, spend much time discussing his critics, or those elements of his work that have not stood the test of time â in my eyes at least. It is clear that, within the confines and context of late 19th and early 20th century scientific achievement and European culture, there was much that Bergson cannot have seen and must, perhaps inevitably, have missed. Nor can one volume address the whole range of the new sciences of complexity â let alone in the context of the ideas of a French philosopher.
This book attempts, nonetheless, to suggest that there are elements of the philosophical perspective which Bergson brought to understanding the world â and specifically evolution â that chime exceedingly well with some of the core arguments of complexity theory found in its stronghold of environmental biology. Indeed, Bergsonâs ideas not only seem to underline and validate those scientific ideas with philosophical argument, but to expand upon them, suggesting to us a broader picture, with implications even wider than the sciences of complexity â already broad â have yet reached. Crucially, this perspective suggests an even further break from past approaches that the complexity sciences have yet to embrace; but which, when seen through the lens of Bergsonâs perspective, make cogent and compelling sense.
In short, the trajectory of the complexity sciences in post-Darwinian evolutionary biology is supported and clarified by some of Bergsonâs ideas, and â I argue in this book â we can gain a great deal of further insight from considering the two together. Ultimately, Bergsonâs concept of creative evolution (as described in his famous book of the same name), underpinned by his earlier works, may have both found scientific verification in contemporary complex evolutionary biology, and have further â fundamental â messages that complexity scientists should heed. In the end, I suggest a new understanding, which I have called creative emergence: it combines elements of Bergsonâs approach and that of the foundational ecological complexity theoristsâ into a new poststructuralist understanding of evolution, and of our place in the world.
Bergson viewed his work as a collaborative research project between science and philosophy, with the common aim of understanding life. His evolutionism, and his philosophy in general, he said, âwill only be built up by the collective and progressive effort of many thinkers, of many observers also, completing, correcting and improving one another.â1 This book is my attempt to further this âcollective and progressive effortâ.
This first chapter briefly reviews the life of the French philosopher, his legacy, and offers an abstract of the rest of the book. The second chapter details those of Bergsonâs core ideas of most relevance to the argument of this book. The third chapter reviews the rediscovery of Bergson at the foundation of poststructuralism, and some of the more recent scholarship around his ideas. The fourth chapter offers a poststructuralist genealogy of systems thinking as it has grown and changed since the 19th century, up until the advent of complexity. The fifth chapter, after addressing the question of time in classical and quantum physics, places the ideas of complexity theory and those of Bergson side by side, and posits a new approach which combines aspects of both. The sixth and final chapter offers a brief conclusion, with a consideration of our place in the world.
On Bergsonâs life
Henri-Louis Bergson was born on 18 October 1859 in Paris to a Polish Jew â a music teacher and composer â and a Jewess from the north of England, thanks to whom he was familiar with English from a young age.2 Coincidentally, 1859 was the same year as the publication of Darwinâs Origin of Species. Following a typical Jewish education he attended the LycĂ©e Condorcet in Paris. While at the LycĂ©e Bergson won prizes for his scientific work, and in 1877, aged 18, won a ânational prize in mathematicsâ3 for the solution of a mathematical problem, which was published the following year in the Nouvelles Annales de MathĂ©matiques â his first published work.4
At 19 he entered the famous Ăcole Normale SupĂ©rieure, where he read and became enamoured of the work of polymath and materialist Herbert Spencer. His education included the fields of literature, the natural sciences and philosophy, and âthe scholastic record he left behind him was one of uniform brilliance.â5 Obtaining the degree of AgrĂ©gation de philosophie in 1881, he became a philosophy teacher at the Angers LycĂ©e, in Anjou. In 1883 he moved to the LycĂ©e Blaise-Pascal in Clermont-Ferraud, where he gave courses on the Presocratics, particularly Heraclitus. It was here that a major change occurred in his thinking, setting him against his earlier love of Spencer. In a letter of 9 May 1908 â to American pragmatist philosopher, William James, with whom he had a long and cordial association â Bergson provided a short paragraph on âevents worthy of noteâ in his life, of which he said there were none in his career, and only one, on the subjective side:
I cannot but attribute great importance to the change which took place in my way of thinking during the two years which followed my leaving the Ăcole Normale, from 1881 to 1883 ... . It was the analysis of the notion of time, as it enters into mechanics and physics, which overturned my ideas. I saw, to my great astonishment, that scientific time does not endure, that it would involve no change in our scientific knowledge if the totality of the real were unfolded all at once, instantaneously, and that positive science consists essentially in the elimination of duration.6
As if to underline this shift, in 1884 he published a translation of Lucretiusâ poem, De rerum natura (On the Nature of Things), with his own commentary attached, already exploring what Gilles Deleuze would later describe as a counter history of philosophy.7
Returning to Paris in 1888, Bergson taught at College Rollin, and then at the Lycée Henri-Quatre, where he read Darwin and gave a course on his theories. His time in the provinces had not been wasted, however, and on his return to Paris he submitted his doctoral thesis, Essai sur les données immédiates de la conscience, which was published in 1889 (appearing in English as Time and Free Will in 1910). His Latin text, Quid Aristoteles de loco senserit, also published in 1889, was submitted alongside it.
In 1896 Bergson published MatiĂšre et mĂ©moire, (which appeared in English as Matter and Memory in 1911) and in 1898 he was able to leave the world of lycĂ©es behind, and was appointed MaĂźtre de ConfĂ©rence (roughly equivalent in the UK to the post of Reader, or to the US Associate Professor) at his old college, LâĂcole Normale SupĂ©rieure, where barely a year later he was promoted to Professor.
In 1900 he was awarded the Chair of Greek and Latin Philosophy at the CollĂšge de France, âone of the highest academic posts in the nationâ.8 His essay Introduction Ă la mĂ©taphysique was published in the Revue de MĂ©taphysique et de Morale in 1903 (appearing in English as Introduction to Metaphysics in 1913), and in 1904 he was appointed as Chair of Modern Philosophy, which post he kept until retirement.
His most famous work, LâEvolution CrĂ©atrice, was published in 1907 (appearing in English as Creative Evolution in 1911). This work was highly celebrated and made him a figure of international repute: âPeople from all over the world came to Paris to hear him lecture, which he did with the same grace, felicity of phrase and originality of thought exhibited in his books. Yet neither the widespread adulation, nor the many honors he received had any effect on his modest, unassuming personality. Like all genuinely great men he possessed true humility of soul.â9 So famous did he become that, between 1909 and 1911 âover two hundred articles about Bergson appeared in the British Press aloneâ10 and he gave lectures in Oxford and Birmingham in 1911, and in New York in 1913. His popularity was riding so high among Catholic modernists that Catholic philosopher Jacques Maritain and others sought âto put Bergsonâs works on the Catholic Index of prohibited material. They succeeded in 1914 â the same year in which Bergson was elected to the AcadĂ©mie Française.â11
Bergson enjoyed, then, until the outbreak of the First World War, the life of an extremely successful academic. But in 1916 his life took an unexpected twist: âthe French government entrusted him with a series of diplomatic missions, first to Spain, and then again decisively, to the United States, in 1917.â12 This diplomatic voyage to the US was to try to convince President Woodrow Wilson to bring America into the war. âTo what extent his effort influenced events is difficult to assess,â13 but the personal relationship Bergson formed with Woodrow Wilson continued during the drafting of the treaty of Versailles, in which Bergson âcontinued to serve as a key intermediary between the French and American governmentsâ.14 Thereafter, his main âpost-war political contribution was his work with the Wilson administration to establish the League of Nationsâ.15 The League was an intergovernmental organisation, founded in 1920 ...
Table of contents
- Cover
- Title
- 1Â Â Introduction
- 2Â Â Bergsons Core Ideas
- 3Â Â Bergson Redux
- 4Â Â Systems Theory Grows Up
- 5Â Â Dure Complexe
- 6Â Â Creative Emergence
- Glossary
- Index