1. What is happiness?
One of the criticisms often levelled at positive psychology is that itâs all about the âbig Hâ: happiness. I mean, happiness is a frivolous topic isnât it? Certainly not one worthy of serious scientific endeavour. Yet when you start digging deeper, it becomes clear that happiness is not at all straightforward. In fact, itâs a pretty complex concept. In this chapter weâll explore some of the components of happiness (or well-being as itâs often called), look at how theyâre measured and why they matter.
Probably the simplest way to get a handle on happiness is to divide it initially into two basic components:
The distinction between these two aspects of happiness dates way back to the ancient Greek philosophers Aristippus (c. 435â356 BCE), who championed hedonism, and Aristotle (384â322 BCE), who advocated eudaimonism.
According to Aristippus, the goal of life is to maximize pleasure and minimize displeasure or pain. In positive psychology hedonic well-being is often used to refer to the happiness you get from feeling pleasure in the moment, pure and simple; itâs the âwine, women and songâ variety of happiness, the one which usually springs to mind when youâre asked what happiness is. Itâs typically short-lived though; we have to keep topping up our reserves in order to maintain its effects (see more about this in Chapter 2). One of the problems with defining happiness solely in terms of sensory pleasure is that, paradoxically, some human desires, even if they are pleasureâproducing in the short term, are not good for you in the long term.
And what about eudaimonic well-being? If happiness can ever have a serious side, this is it! As we suggested above, some people believe that pleasure on its own isnât sufficient to describe the totality of human well-being. According to Aristotle, merely pursuing pleasure is vulgar; he advocated eudaimonism because he believed that true happiness is found in doing what is worth doing, not in having a good time. Eudaimonic well-being is a broad term used by positive psychologists to refer to the happiness we gain from having meaning and purpose in our lives, fulfilling our potential and feeling that we are part of something bigger than ourselves.
But even eudaimonic well-being is not problem-free. Some psychologists dislike its moral overtones; they argue that it isnât psychologyâs job to prescribe what is good for people. And paradoxically, eudaimonic well-being may not provide any pleasurable feelings at all! In fact, it may involve considerable personal hardship and effort over the longer term. Yet it is suggested that eudaimonia leads to greater life satisfaction than pure pleasure alone.
In practice, positive psychologists donât agree on the definition of eudaimonic well-being (terms include âself-actualizationâ, âpersonal expressivenessâ, âmeaningâ, âpersonal growthâ, âengagementâ and âflowâ). Nor do they agree on how it should be measured, and often the term eudaimonic well-being is used as a catch-all for any type of happiness that isnât hedonic. But even if weâre not yet sure how to define eudaimonic well-being, most people would acknowledge that thereâs more to true happiness than a few pints in the pub on Friday night and a game of golf on Sunday! Psychology research concurs with this: a recent study of over 13,000 people suggests that pursuing engagement or meaning are more strongly related to well-being than pursuing pleasure.
Another area of disagreement for positive psychologists is whether happiness is a subjective or objective phenomenon. Some definitions of eudaimonic well-being suggest that there is an objective standard against which peopleâs lives can be judged. On the other hand, there are psychologists who insist that happiness is a subjective phenomenon. They argue that it can only be measured by asking people to rate their own happiness. This leads us to another definition of happiness often used in positive psychology â Subjective Well-Being (SWB) â which is expressed in the following formula:
Satisfaction with Life + Positive Emotion â Negative Emotion
In simple terms this means that subjective happiness consists of three elements, one cognitive (or evaluative) and two affective:
Satisfaction with life: what I think about my life (does it measure up to my expectations and resemble my âidealâ life?)
plus
The presence of positive emotion: how positive I feel
less
The presence of negative emotion: how negative I feel
Using Subjective Well-Being as the measure suggests that to increase our level of happiness overall we should focus on minimizing our negative mood and maximizing our life satisfaction and positive mood.
Measuring your Subjective Well-Being
First of all, measure your life satisfaction. You can use Diener and colleaguesâ Satisfaction with Life Scale.
Then measure how you feel. To do this you can use the Positive and Negative Affect Scale (PANAS) which we look at in Chapter 11, or the Scale of Positive and Negative Experience (SPANE). See the Resources section for details of these assessment tools.
How did you fare? Were you surprised by the outcome? If the results werenât as high as youâd like, how might you increase your life satisfaction and your positive mood, or decrease your negative mood? Write some notes in your well-being journal.
A positive psychology model of well-being
In his most recent book, Flourish, Martin Seligman, one of the founding fathers of the positive psychology movement, describes his new theory of well-being. His model (PERMA), which consists of five separate elements, draws on aspects of both hedonic and eudaimonic well-being:
Positive emotion is exactly what it says â the experience of positive mood and feelings which are uplifting. As we have already mentioned, there are various questionnaires you can use to measure positive (and negative) emotional states. Weâll explore positive emotions, their role in your happiness and their benefits in Chapter 3, and the concept of emotional intelligence in Chapter 11.
Engagement (or âflowâ as itâs often called) refers to the well-being you get from being totally absorbed in the task in hand, so much so that you lose track of time and feel completely at one with what youâre doing. When sportsÂpeople talk about âbeing in the zoneâ, theyâre referring to their experience of flow. Flow is usually measured by asking people to reflect back on their day and record flow experiences or by having them carry an electronic beeper which randomly prompts them to think about and record what theyâre doing at that moment in time. For more about flow, see Chapter 4.
Relationships are included in Seligmanâs model because research suggests that good, caring and supportive interpersonal connections are essential to your well-being at any age in life. For more about positive relationships, see Chapter 5.
Meaning is important because it provides both a stable foundation and a sense of direction in life. Pursuing meaningful activities has been found to be more strongly related to happiness than pursuing pleasurable ones. There are many different measures of meaning, although itâs still a relatively under-researched area. The Sources of Meaning and Meaning in Life Questionnaire (SoMe) measures 26 different sources, including self-transcendence (such as spirituality), self-actualization (such as challenge and knowledge), order (such as tradition and holding on to values), and well-being and caring for others (such as community and love). For more on meaning, see Chapter 6.
Accomplishment is the latest psychological component in Seligmanâs well-being model. Itâs another broad category which includes everything from achievement, success and mastery at the highest level possible to progress towards goals and competence. For more information, activities and insights into accomplishment and its relationship to well-being, turn to Chapter 7.
Now letâs explore how these five facets of well-being appear in your life at the moment.
The Wheel of Well-Being
- Thinking about your life in general, which of your day-to-day activities give you pleasure or joy? Which ones are engaging (put you into flow)? Which ones are centred on building supportive relationships (e.g. with family, friends, colleagues, customers or others)? Which activities are meaningful? And which ones give you a sense of accomplishment, and make you feel that you have made a difference?
- Once you have formed a snapshot of these in your m...