1
MOMENTS OF great import are often tinged with darkness because perversely we yearn to be let down. And so it was that I found myself in late September 2002 at my first solo show in Paris feeling neither proud nor encouraged by the crowds of people who had come out to support my paintings, but saddened. Disappointed. If you had told me ten years ago that Iād be building my artistic reputation on a series of realistic oil paintings of rooms viewed through a keyhole, I would have pointed to my mixed-media collages of driftwood and saw blades and melted plastic ramen packets, the miniature green plastic soldiers I had implanted inside of Bubble Wrap, I would have jacked up the bass on the electronic musician Peachesā Fancypants Hoodlum album and told you I would never sell out.
And yet here I was, surrounded by thirteen narrative paintings that depicted rooms I had lived in, or in some way experienced with various women over the course of my life, all of these executed with barely visible brushstrokes in a palette of oil colors that would look good on any wall, in any context, in any country. They werenāt contentious, they certainly werenāt political, and they were selling like mad.
Now, my impression that Iād sold out was a private one, shared neither by my gallerist, Julien, happily traipsing about the room affixing red dots to the drywall, nor by the swell of brightly dressed expatriates pushing their way through conversations to knock their plastic glasses of Chablis against mine. There was nothing to be grim about; I was relatively young and this was Paris, and this night was a night that Iād been working toward for some time. But from the minute Iād seen Julien place a red sticker underneath the first painting Iād done in the series, The Blue Bear, Iād been plagued by the feeling that Iād done something irreversible, that I wasnāt where I was supposed to be, that I hadnāt been for months. Worse yet, I had no anchor, no one to set me back on course. My wife of seven years, a no-Ānonsense French lawyer who had stuck by my side in grad school as I showcased found sculptures constructed from other peopleās rubbish and dollhouses made out of Barbie Doll packaging, was a meter of my creative decline. Anne-Laure de Bourigeaud was not going to lie and tell me that Iād made it. The person who would have, the one person who I wanted to comfort and reboost me, was across the Channel with a man who was more reliable, easygoing, more available than me. And so it fell to the red stickers and the handshakes of would-be patrons to fuel me with self-worth. But halfway through the evening, with my own wife brightly sparkling in front of everyone but me, I was unmoored and drifting, tempted to sink.
ā¢ ā¢ ā¢
In the car after the opening, Anne thrust the Peugeot into first gear. Driving stick in Paris is cathartic when sheās anxious. I often let her drive.
Anne strained against her seat belt, reaching out to verify that our daughter was wearing hers.
āYou all right, princess?ā I asked, turning around also.
Camille smoothed out the billowing layers of the ruffled pink tube skirt sheād picked out for Dadās big night.
āNon . . .ā she said, yawning.
āYou didnāt take the last Yop, right?ā This was asked of me, by my wife.
The streetlight cut into the car, illuminating the steering wheel, the dusty dashboard, the humming, buzzing electroland of our interior mobile world. Anne had had her hair done. I knew better than to ask, but I recognized the scent of the hairspray that made its metallic strawberry way, twice a month, into our lives.
I looked into her eyes that she had lined beautifully in the nonchalant and yet studied manner of the French. I forced a smile.
āNo, I didnāt.ā
āGood,ā she said, edging the car out of the parking spot. āCam-Cam, weāll have a little snack when we get home.ā
Paris. Paris at night. Paris at night is a street show of a hundred moments you might have lived. You might have been the couple beneath the streetlamp by the Place de la Concorde, holding out a camera directed at themselves. You might have been the old man on the bridge, staring at the houseboats. You might have been the person that girl was smiling in response to as she crossed that same bridge on her cell phone. Or you might be a man in a shitty French export engaged in a discussion about liquid yogurt with his wife. Paris is a city of a hundred million lights, and sometimes they flicker. Sometimes they go out.
Anne pushed on the radio, set it to the news. The molten contralto of the female announcer filled the silence of our car. āAt an opening of a meeting at Camp David, British Prime Minister Tony Blair fully endorsed President Bushās intention to find and destroy the weapons of mass destruction purportedly hidden in Iraq.ā And then the reedy liltings of my once-proud prime minister: āThe policy of inaction is not a policy we can responsibly subscribe to.ā
āRight,ā said Anne. āInaction.ā
āItās madness,ā I said, ignoring her pointed phrasing. āPeople getting scared because theyāre told to be. Without asking why.ā
Anne flicked on the blinker.
āItās mostly displacement, I think. Verschiebung.ā She tilted her chin up, proud of her arsenal of comp lit terms stored from undergrad. āThe big questions are too frightening. You know, where to actually place blame. So theyāve picked an easy target.ā
āYou think France will go along with it?ā
Her eyes darkened. āNever.ā
I looked out the window at the endless river below us, dividing the right bank from the left bank, the rich from the richer. āItās a bad sign, though, Blair joining up,ā I added. āI mean, the British? We used to question things to death.ā
Anne nodded and fell silent. The announcer went on to summarize the fiscal situation across the Eurozone since the introduction of the euro in January of 2002.
Anne turned down the volume and looked in the rearview mirror. āCam, honey. Did you have a good time?ā
āUm, it was okay,ā our daughter, Camille, said, fiddling with her dress. āMy favorite is the one with all the bicycles and then the, um, the one in the kitchen, and then the one with the blue bear that used to be in my room.ā
I closed my eyes at all the women, even the small ones, who wield words like wands; their phrases sugary and innocuous one minute, corrosive the next.
Aesthetically, The Blue Bear was one of the largest and thus most expensive paintings in the show, but because I had originally painted it as a gift for Anne, it was also the most barbed.
At 117 x 140 cm, The Blue Bear is an oil painting of the guest room in a friendās rickety, draft-ridden house in Centerville, Cape Cod, where weād planned to spend the summer after grad school riding out the what-now crests of our midtwenties and to consider baby-making, whichāif it wouldnāt answer the āwhat now?ā questionāwould certainly answer āwhat next?ā
The first among our group of friends to get married, it felt rebellious and artistic to consider having a child while we were still young and thin of limb and riotously in love. We also thought, however, that we were scheming in dreamland, safe beneath the mantra that has been the downfall of so many privileged white people: an unplanned pregnancy canāt happen to us.
Color us surprised, then, when a mere five weeks after having her IUD removed, Anne missed her period and started to notice a distinct throbbing in her breasts. We thought it was funnyāso symbiotic were we in our tastes and desires that a mere discussion could push a possibility into being. We were delightedāamused, even. We felt blessed.
During those first few weeks on the Cape, I was still making sculptures out of found objects, and Anne, a gifted illustrator, was interspersing her studies for the European bar with new installments of a zine sheād started while studying abroad in Boston. A play on words with āAnneā (her name) and Ć¢ne (the French word for ādonkeyā), Ćne in America depicted the missteps of a shy, pessimistic Parisian indoctrinated into the boisterous world of cotton-candy-hearted, light-beer-guzzling Americans who relied on their inexhaustible optimism to see them through all things.
But as the summer inched on and I watched her caress her growing belly as she read laminated hardcovers from the town library, a curious change came over this Englishman who up until that point had been the enemy of sap. I became a sentimentalist, a tenderheart, an easy-listening sop. Much like how the lack of oxygen in planes makes us tear up at the most improbable of romantic comedies, as that child grew within Anne into a living, true-blue thing instead of a discussed possibility, I lost interest in the sea glass and the battered plastic cans and the porous wood Iād been using all summer and was filled with the urge to paint something lovely for her. For them both.
The idea of painting a scene viewed through a keyhole came to me when I happened upon Anne in the bedroom one morning pondering a stuffed teddy bear that our friends, the houseās owners, had left for us on a chair as an early baby gift. They were, at that point, our closest friends and the first people we had told about the pregnancy, but there was something about that stuffed animal that was both touching and foreboding. Would the baby play with it? Would the baby live? I could see the mix of trepidation and excitement playing over Anneās face as she turned the stuffed brown thing over in her hands, and it comforted me to know that I wasnāt alone with my roller-coaster rides between pridefulness and fear.
And stillāAnne is a woman, and I, rather evidently, am not. There was a great difference between what was happening to her and what was potentially happeningāgoing to happenāto us. Which is how I got the idea to approach the scene from a distance, as an outsider, a voyeur.
Except for the tattered rug and the rocking chair beside a window with a view of the gray sea, I left the room uninhabited save for the stuffed bear that I painted seated on the rocking chair, a bit larger than it was in real life, and not at all brown. I painted the bear blue, and not a dim pastel color that might have been a trick of the light and sea, but a vibrating cerulean that lent to the otherwise staid atmosphere a pulsating point of interest. Unsettling in some lights, calming in othersāthe blue stood for the thrill of the unknown.
When I gave the painting to Anne, she never asked why the bear was blue. She knew why, inherently, and in the giving of the painting, I felt doubly convinced that I loved her, that I truly loved her, that I would love her for all time. What other woman could wordlessly accept such a confession? A tangible depiction of both happiness and fear?
In the fall, that painting traveled with our belongings in a ship across the Atlantic, and it waited in a Parisian storage center until the birth of our daughter, when we finally had a home. We hung it in the nursery, ignoring the comments from certain friends and in-laws that the bear would have been a lot less off-putting and child appropriate if it hadnāt been blue. The very fact that other people didnāt seem to āget itā convinced us that we had a shared sensibility, something truly special, making the painting more important than a private joke.
We continued feeling that way until Camille turned three and started plastering her walls with her own drawings and paper cutouts and origami birds, and we began to feel like weād enforced something upon her that only meant something to us. So we put it in the basement, intending to scout for a new bookshelf system so that we would have enough wall space to hang the painting in our bedroom. But then I met Lisa, and too much time had passed, and when The Blue Bear was brought up, the discussions were accusatory, spiteful. And so it stayed in the basement, hidden out of sight, not so much forgotten as disdained.
Months later, when I st...