Breath and Holistic Practice
JANE BOSTON AND RENA COOK
An extended gaze eastwards has been incorporated into western performance praxis for the greater part of the twentieth century onwards, in part to refresh and revalue its own moribund traditions. The origin of this gaze is complex but its recent incarnation relates in part to the liberation philosophies of the 1960s with their reaction to the authoritarian structures and materialistic values of the previous decade. This gave rise to a myriad of ânewâ thinking about established orthodoxies that were mirrored by many involved with the theory and practices of performance. These all shared similar cultural origins, reflected a West to East gaze and were almost exclusively holistic in nature.
Tara McAllister-Viel takes us eastwards with her subtle account of the ways in which the dualistic thinking embedded in western philosophy may have limited the conceptualization of the breath. She examines the place of breath in relation to the bodyâmind dichotomies and invites us to adopt a different and more holistic approach informed by other cultural practices and values. Interweaving her own cultural background in the States with those discovered in Korea, she offers specific observations about the ways in which the arts of Dahnjeon breathing can provide efficient muscular use as a foundation for good breath and vocal use.
As well as looking to the Far East, the gaze has also gone specifically to the indigenous cultures of the world. The chapter by Marj McDaid draws upon Central and Eastern Europe where she explores the evolution of her own breathing practice based on the influence of the Eastern Siberian teacher Nelly Dougar-Zhabon whose practice involves not only the influence of Siberian shamanism, but also Tibetan Dynamic Meditation and Qi Gong. An approach based upon a synthesis of methods, with reference to their specific implications for actor training processes, forms the basis of this chapter.
Michael Morgan follows with an exploration of the ways in which the exterior forms of of Chinese Qi Gong, such as acupuncture, martial arts, stretching and massage and the interior forms, such as a range of internal breathing methods, can relate to western mindbody training. He suggests that âquestions, rather than answersâ should provide the most fruitful starting point for this complex examination involving forms that have been cultivated in one context and then transplanted to another.
Debbie Green, in an account of the evolution of her movement practice, places importance on the sensual activity of the breath. She instructively concludes that this, too, will vary between practices: âthe movement we do on the out-breath in Pilates or Bartenieff Fundamentals may well be different from those we do in Yoga, but in any of these, connection to personal breath is keyâ. Whilst her focus begins with the actor, it is clearly relevant to all who work with the body from an intercultural and an interdisciplinary perspective. Her focus on the core energy of the breath suggests that everyone can access and benefit from it, creating a sense of multi-dimensionality where âthe outside (is) informed by the inside through the breathâ (Green).
Rena Cook looks specifically at the healing methodologies of the East in order to reinvigorate the breathing practices of the western academies that have become stale and reliant on old mechanistic models and interrogates the question of âauthenticityâ within both presence and performance. Where the more traditional western practices have been seen by some to be tainted with outmoded thought and knowledge, an account is provided as to why it has been to the older, deemed more âspiritualâ, practices of the East that many practitioners have turned. Here, where they have found a more convincing unity of heart and mind, it is seen that the breath can provide a crucial meeting point between the conscious and the unconscious mind and offer synthesis rather than division.
CHAPTER 8
Dahnjeon Breathing
TARA MCALLISTER-VIEL
Breathing through âdahnjeon(s)â is a way of breathing that can be found in many different Asian modes of training. The particular exercise called âDahnjeon Breathingâ found at the end of this chapter is an exercise adapted from my experiences of long-term, rigorous study of several Asian practices.1 Regular practice with these exercises will help you create efficient muscular use as the foundation for good breath and voice production. Long-term, rigorous practice will help you cultivate ki (energy), which will give your sound a sense of strength beyond muscular strength. These exercises will also provide the foundation for creating a sense of being in the here and now and help create the necessary preparation for drawing in your listener and sustaining communication. Before you begin the exercise sequence, it is important to understand:
â˘What is dahnjeon(s)?
â˘How breathing from the (lower) dahnjeon helps train the voice?
â˘How using this breathing practice can benefit your voice training?
WHAT IS A âDAHNJEONâ?
Sometimes âdahnjeonâ is translated into English as âcentreâ,or âenergy centreâ (Benedetti 1990, p.28â9). Dahnjeon(s) are a part of an eastern understanding of the body integral to eastern medicinal praxis and fundamental to the way the body functions. There are three internal dahnjeons and four external dahnjeons. The âlower dahnjeonâ also referred to as dantien or tan-den (Japan) or nabhi mula (Sanskrit meaning âthe root of the navelâ),2 is located two inches below the navel and two inches inside the body. The âmiddle dahnjeonâ is located two inches inside the body behind the sternum, and the âupper dahnjeonâ, is located roughly between and just above the eyes within the forehead (also referred to in some Asian practices as the âmindâs eyeâ, the âinner eyeâ or âthird eyeâ). There are four external dahnjeons, one located in the palm of each hand where the centre fingernail touches the palm while fisting (jangshim in Korean) and one located on the bottom of each foot, just below the ball when the foot is flexed (yongchun in Korean).3
This body knowledge becomes the foundation for the transmission of embodied practices. Because the exercise at the end of this chapter focuses on the lower dahnjeon, I will concentrate on this area in order to better explain one understanding of how a dahnjeon can function in developing the breath for sounding.
THE LOWER DAHNJEON AND TRAINING THE VOICE
Sometimes the lower dahnjeon as an âenergy centreâ is compared to a western understanding of âcentre of gravityâ in the body because both are formless and invisible but have palpable physiological effects on the body (Benedetti 1990, p.28â9). However, the lower dahnjeon works differently from centre of gravity. Breathing through the lower dahnjeon trains the mind through the body, cultivating an intense bodymind relationship and âkiâ (Korea), also referred to as âchiâ (China) âqiâ (Japan), âpranaâ or âpranavayuâ (India). Ki moves in/through/around the bodymind through âdahnjeonsâ and a system of channels called âmeridiansâ (kyung lack in Korean), travelling down the back of the body (yang energy) and up the front of the body (eum or yin energy) in a cyclical process, alternating between eum-yang polarities in the body (Yuasa 1993, p.75â6; Yoo in CTR 2007, p.87).
When breathing through the lower dahnjeon while voicing, the resultant sound manifests a sense of strength that cannot be explained through the bodyâs muscularity alone.4 Abdominal muscle(s) are used in combination with breathing energy or ki, creating a strong resonant sound that is compelling to listen to.
DAHNJEON BREATHING AND TRAINING THE VOICE THROUGH BODYMIND
Sometimes the energy of the breath can be understood through training metaphors. Here, I am referring to breathing energy, or ki, as a physical reality and material condition of training and performance. Not only can the practitioner feel this energy, sometimes recognized as heat or vibrations, but the listener can hear within the sound a concentration of focused awareness during communication.
One use of breath/ki for the practitioner is to prepare and sustain the breath for sounding. To better understand how this might work, we can find insights from one of the earliest explanations. Zeami Motokiyo (1364â1443), in his treatise Kakyo, discussed how ki functioned when training the Japanese Noh actorâs voice, âFirst the Key; Second the Activating Force (chi); Third, the Voice.â Mark Nearman explains his interpretation of Zeamiâs instruction,
That which inwardly must receive, preserve and sustain tonal pitch is identified as the actorâs châi. Before attempting to vocalize, an actor should first listen to the sound of the flute or in the case of a student, the teacherâs voice. On the basis of that externally produced tonality, the actor should determine his âtonal center,â by âhearingâ and sustaining it within his own mind. He experiences that tone as âvibratingâ within himself, particularly in his tanden (dahnjeon). The performer then âcloses his eyes,â that is, he concentrates on that tonal center to the exclusion of all external âvisualâ stimuli, and inhales. Only when he has gone through this process is ...